Every trip to the gas pump feels like a rigged pop quiz that you will flunk no matter what. Will fuel cost unbundling finally give us the cheat sheet to be truly informed and consequently generate savings—or are we just dreaming?
For over two decades since the deregulation of the downstream oil industry, Filipino consumers have been piecing together the puzzle of pump prices – and they have some weekly grumble that typically, oil companies feast on price hikes like a stacked buffet but will just toss out rollbacks like crumbs or tiny bits akin to forcing you to be on a strict diet.
Undeniably, Filipino consumers have been confused over what exactly they’re paying for at the gas pumps. Is it just the cost of oil? Or is it a tangled mess of hidden charges—from international import fees to taxes, biofuel costs, and the oil companies' profit pie? These are like hidden treasures that we’re already trying to dig deep into for far too long – as if we’re too desperate to glimpse what’s being kept out of sight.
A Department of Energy (DOE) Circular issued in 2019 aims to solve that riddle by mandating the unbundling of fuel price components. However, industry players fired back with legal cases, claiming that the policy would spill their 'trade secrets' and could cause 'irreparable injury' to their business operations, which may consequently affect their competitive edge—a defense that the lower courts had upheld.
The oil companies have repeatedly asserted that while weekly price adjustments may come with uniform announcements, the reality at the pumps tells a different story—actual prices often shift due to market forces, with stations either compelled to match or surpass their competitors' price hikes or reductions to snatch customers away.
Unlocking ‘secrets’ of fuel pricing
The DOE Circular (DC2019-05-0008) demands oil firms break down at least four key cost components: a) international costs (import, freight, insurance, and exchange rates); b) taxes and duties (excise, value-added tax and other imposts); c) biofuel costs; and d) the oil companies take —from port charges to refining, storage, handling as well as marketing costs; and of course, their profit margin.
After nearly five years of heated legal battles, this year’s Supreme Court verdict delivered a decisive blow to the oil industry-petitioners, ruling that their claims of "irreparable injury" due to the DOE Circular mandating price unbundling were unfounded. In a no-nonsense judgment, the high court stipulated that the petitioners “failed to establish a substantial or material invasion of a clear and unmistakable right" against implementing the fuel cost unbundling policy.
In its ruling, the Supreme Court bluntly stated, "Since there is no legal right in the first place, there can be no irreparable injury to speak of." In other words, if the oil companies had no solid legal basis for claiming harm, their argument fell apart. The Court’s message was clear: no rights were being violated, and no damage could be proven.
Taking a hard cue from the ruling, the high court’s decision now forces oil companies to accept the fuel cost unbundling policy, potentially leveling the playing field for consumers and offering much-needed clarity in a sector consistently criticized for lack of transparency.
What does this mean for Filipino consumers who have long felt the sting of inflated fuel prices? It’s some sort of win—that is, if the policy is enforced properly and if consumers are genuinely informed and educated on the complex web of oil pricing—not just from the domestic standpoint of their operations but, more importantly, the global factors driving the daily-to-weekly price rollercoaster.
The major dilemma of the Philippines is that: it is heavily oil import-dependent and with a demand that is just a ‘drop in the bucket’ compared to ‘heavyweight economies’ - it has zero control over the wild fluctuations of global oil prices—an undeniable reality that casts a long shadow over the country’s energy security ambitions.
And even for seasoned journalists who’ve spent years covering the energy sector, grasping the global dynamics of oil pricing remains a mind-bender —thanks to the chaotic blend of geopolitical power plays and market speculations that can send prices soaring in an instant.
This coming Tuesday (December 10), consumers will be met with fuel price rollback – a relatively welcome development so to speak. But let's be honest, that same old mystery is still stuck in your mind: what the heck are you actually paying for when you fill up this time?
According to the latest industry buzz, oil companies will soon be required to hand over weekly and yearly reports on their itemized costs pass-on at the pumps. Sounds promising? But the real kicker might be whether those reports will truthfully reveal actual numbers or remain buried in bureaucratic paperwork.
For feedback and suggestions, please email at: [email protected]